Season 3 Episode 5: How I Met Everyone Else Discussion

howimeteveryoneelse0.jpg
“I don’t care. I’ve been with one woman for too long and I need some strange.”

What Was Good

  • Pamela Fryman is back!
  • Barney’s chart is funny. It’s just pushing the “trying too hard” line though. Although I have a feeling the Mendosa Diagonal is going to enter the general vocabulary…
  • The story of how Marshall and Barney met is my favorite. Tricking Barney into thinking he was trying to pick up that stranger was genius.
  • We finally saw the scene where Ted and Marshall meet that was described in “Where Were We”. We also saw lesson four of Barney’s lessons for life the night he and Ted met which references back all the way to the pilot.
  • I love that when Lily brings up the guy she made out with before she even met Marshall, over seven years ago, Marshall remembers through gritted teeth and when Ted brings up the girl that he made out with the same night Marshall remembers with a proud smile.
  • The prolonged sandwich metaphor.
  • A World of Warcraft reference! That hits a little too close to home for me. Although it puts me and Ted back in the “alike” column after last week’s hip hop mishap. I’m more than a little bit sad to admit that a) I saw it coming that the female avatar was going to be Ted because…I had a female avatar and b) Blah Blah was a Draenei Warrior and Ted was a Human Mage. Yeah…

What Was Bad

howimeteveryoneelse2.jpg

  • I hate girls like Blah Blah. They’re not funny, they just make me mad. Who is willing to tell a guy’s lifelong best friend a deep secret at the drop of a hat? I suppose it’s really Ted’s fault, you can’t really blame the stove for burning you if you know it’s hot.
  • I’m concerned the show is getting too self referential. It was funny when there was a joke about a character saying “no” a lot in repetition in last year’s finale, it wasn’t as funny tonight.
  • With all the girls whispering sexy proposals into guys’ ears that makes them cave in on whatever secret/purchase/favor they’re holding out on has begged the question: what could a girl possibly offer that would make a guy do a 180 like that? Nothing I can think of. It’s becoming a plot device.
  • Our favorite friends haven’t aged very well, have they? Although, this is pretty hilarious.

Favorite Moments

“Alright but spoiler alert: it ends with everyone saying ‘aww’. It starts with it too.”
“Dude this black-haired, goth chick stopped by today. WANNA TAP IT!”
“Let them drink their $1 beers. Try this, it’s a pinot noir from Europe. Yeah, I cut it with cranberry juice, it was pretty strong.”
“While you were busy majoring in being freaking beautiful I was starting my own line of handbags.”
“Lily, come on. Lily, come on. Lily…come on.”
“I’m your bro. I’m broda.”
and one of the best, if not most hand-fisted jokes in the series:

Barney: “And tonight you’re going to use The Force to get the hottest chick in this bar into bed.”
Ted: “He’s gonna use force? Because that sounds wrong broda.”

“I don’t need this. I design handbags. I’m a superstar!”
“Where’s my wife?”

Barney’s Vocab Word of the Week

howimeteveryoneelse1.jpg

Mendosa Diagonal
–noun
The 1:1 minimum ratio of hotness to craziness as plotted on a line graph a girl must fall above in order to be desirable. As craziness rises, so too must hotness.

If you enjoyed this post, make sure you subscribe to my RSS feed


6 Comments to “Season 3 Episode 5: How I Met Everyone Else Discussion”

  1. Shashwat |  Tuesday, October 23rd, 2007 07:51 am GMT -4

    season 3 has greatly picked up now.. its bad start has been long forgotten.. this episode was not exactly what i would call terrific, because i think the plot wasn’t as complicated as i’ve become used to seeing, but it showed all signs of making HIMYM 1 of TV’s all-time best shows in the long run.. actually i already consider HIMYM in that list

  2. Wes McGee |  Thursday, October 25th, 2007 07:57 am GMT -4

    The Mendoza diagonal is actually a cute riff on a baseball fan term, for a point where a baseball player is just too bad a hitter to justify being in the major leagues.

  3. pedro |  Wednesday, January 30th, 2008 10:51 am GMT -4

    this is….. um…. yeah. not entertaining.

  4. JD |  Wednesday, January 30th, 2008 10:58 am GMT -4

    Pedro,

    Are you referring the show not being entertaining? Or the conversation on this post? Are you a fan of the show? You didn’t elaborate so I’m just wondering what you were referring to. I would’ve emailed you but the address you used bounced back when I tried to contact you.

  5. Canuckflack / Did you cross the Mendoza diagonal last night? |  Friday, February 15th, 2008 09:58 pm GMT -4

    [...] I Met Your Mother this season, Barney explained how your potential mate had to balance off their crazyness with a suitable level of hotness – much like the artists you picked for that [...]

  6. Charla Rosmarin |  Monday, June 21st, 2010 04:24 pm GMT -4

    Hello, I also like the Shrek movies, great film!

Leave a Reply

This is a Gravatar-enabled weblog. If you want your own picture instead of the monster, register for free at Gravatar with the email address you use to comment.


or you can…

Subscribe without commenting

Mondays at 8:00pm on CBS

stay informed

Categories